Just like Andrew Harper editors, our members are an opinionated bunch. Here, they positively gush about four of our recommended hotels — including two seaside resorts — and don’t mince words about a 10-room bed-and-breakfast in California.

This column summarizes the observations of our members and does not necessarily reflect the opinions of Andrew Harper editors. Based on the numerous emails that we receive each month, the following hotels and resorts garnered the most revealing positive and/or negative comments. 

Jumby Bay Island

Antigua