Above: The clubby dark-wood interior of The Rum House

I always like to discuss a show over a civilized nightcap before retiring. These venues serve commendable cocktails in charming surroundings.

Join Andrew Harper today to continue reading our exclusive content.
Above: The clubby dark-wood interior of The Rum House

Read More from Our Trip:

All-Time Favorite Midtown Hotels Theater Memorabilia in New York Tranquil Manhattan Retreats: Midtown Libraries Pre-Theater Dining in New York City